Most small business owners spend the majority of their marketing energy trying to find new people. New followers, new leads, cold audiences they haven’t earned yet. It makes sense on the surface — growth feels like it has to mean new. But there’s a group of people you’re almost certainly underusing: the ones who already trust you.
Your warm audience converts at a higher rate than cold traffic. That’s not a philosophy, it’s just how trust works. Someone who already bought from you, or nearly did, or signed up for your emails because something you said resonated — that person is far more likely to buy than a stranger who just found you. And yet most of us spend about 10% of our effort on them and 90% chasing people who’ve never heard of us.
Part of it is that selling to people who already know you feels presumptuous somehow. Like you’re taking advantage of a relationship. But you’re not — you’re doing the thing they signed up for. They gave you their email address because they wanted to hear from you. So talk to them.
Where your warm audience actually lives
The obvious one is your email list. But there are two ways to reach those people, not one: you can email them directly, and if you’re running Meta ads, you can upload your list and target them there too. Even a small list is worth doing this with. Fifty people who already know you will outperform five thousand cold strangers. Warm traffic is just more valuable, full stop.
Beyond email, your warmest audience is watching your stories. Instagram and Facebook stories are seen almost exclusively by people who already follow you — which makes them a direct line to the people most likely to buy. If you’re posting to your feed but not your stories, you’re broadcasting to strangers and whispering to your warm audience. Flip that ratio.
What to actually say
Here’s where people get stuck. They want to email their list but they don’t know what to say, so they don’t say anything, and the list goes cold.
You don’t need a special occasion. You don’t need a new offer or a big announcement. You can email them about anything you’d post on your social media — because they signed up for the same reason they followed you. Something you said or made or thought resonated with them. Keep saying things. Keep making things. Let the emails sound like you rather than like a campaign.
A sale is a fine reason to reach out, but it’s not the only one. And it’s not always the best one.
On discounts — use them deliberately
A discount will increase sales. That part is true. But use them too often and you train your audience to wait for one, which means full-price sales slow down and you’ve effectively lowered your prices permanently without meaning to.
The version worth setting up: a welcome discount of around 15%, delivered automatically in the confirmation email when someone joins your list. It catches people at their warmest, when they’ve just decided they like you enough to hand over their email address. After that, save discounts for when they mean something. A discount that’s always available is just your price.
The thing most people get wrong about email frequency
If you’re emailing your list less than twice a month, your subscribers are forgetting who you are. And when people forget who you are, they start marking your emails as spam — which means, counterintuitively, that emailing less often actually increases your unsubscribe rate. Silence doesn’t protect the relationship. It erodes it.
Keep your list warm regardless of its size. Twice a month is the floor. More is fine if you have more to say. The upper limit is different for every business and every audience — you’ll find it when your unsubscribes start telling you. That’s data, not rejection.
The challenge
Schedule two emails to go out to your list in the next month. Sell them something. Remind them you exist. Make it sound like you wrote it to a friend, not like you spent three hours on a template — because plain text emails genuinely convert better than designed ones, and this is not the place to perform professionalism.
What are you going to email them about?
Want to do these types of challenges with a group of kick ass women? Join us in the facebook group